MARINA YERESHENKO wrote:
> Judging by the fact that people seem to either hate the movie or love
> it,
> it must have been really outstanding. You have to trully stir people's
>
> feelings to make them start using words like "idiotic".
I don't think I used "idiotic"...and I never said I hated the movie.
Hate is too strong an emotion to be focused on a strip of film...
> First, there was nothing unbelivable about
> Basset character's "devotion" to the guy. In my opinion, this is
> what's
> called _friendship_. Maybe it does not happen too often, but it does
> exist. I'd like to have a friend like her myself. Besides, they show
> things like that between male friends all the time and no one finds it
>
> strange.
I'm thinking more along the lines of co-dependency. Those two did not
have what I would like to think of as a healthy friendship, and the
forced romance was even worse (why can't Lenny just get his life
together without a mother figure in Bassett or a whore figure in
Lewis?).
> About the guy's self-destruction, it's even more realistic.
No, I don't think so. If it were realistic, the movie would be taking
place after Lenny's funeral...no one like that would last as long as he
did - especially after leaving the police force (both the cops and the
criminals would want him dead).
> I'm glad there is an action movie
> where tough men can be upset about a rape victim, even if she's not
> their
> sister or girlfriend as it usually happens.
Agreed. The movie had vast potential there...too bad they couldn't stay
focused (but that's a consistent James Cameron problem through all his
scripts).
> And finally, bad box office is not always an indication of
> worthlessness.
That's true, and no one's arguing that. Some of us are simply saying
that we would have liked to have seen a good film. Instead (IMHO) we
got a mildly silly morality play of a movie that felt like it belonged
more in Bill Bennett's _The Book of Virtues_ than in SF.
> I've heard that Tank Girl did not make a lot of money,
> either, but I think it's way more interesting than all the Batman
> flicks
> combined.
Actually, please don't combine Burton's films with Schumacher's Adam
West retreads...and _Tank Girl_ was seriously lacking in its translation
from comic to film (but that's another story).
- Geoffrey
-- "Time is an illusion. Lunchtime doubly so." - Ford Prefect
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Thu May 25 2000 - 19:07:37 PDT